Showing posts with label Visualization. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Visualization. Show all posts

Saturday, August 26, 2017

Mind over matter

I used to do a form of physical therapy that focused on mind-body connections. Quite often, the therapist would ask me to do something I had no idea how to do – say, to bend some part of my body in a direction I wasn’t aware it could bend at all. But I would try and she seemed to feel that my trying produced some results. So it appeared that it was possible to send a mental command out even without being sure that any part of my body could actually receive the command. One reason this made sense to me was that I had the impression that great athletes, and dancers, and yoga adepts really can do things with their bodies that seem simply inconceivable for others: there are circuits within us that lie dormant, or scarcely perceived, but that can be activated. And trying, mentally, to activate them is itself a part of the process of bringing them into action.

If all that is so, then perhaps the same principle can be applied to cancer. I have no idea how to issue mental commands to my immune system. As far as I can tell, this system operates on its own without any conscious input from me. And yet – what if there is a way to guide my immune system (or other parts of the body’s potential defenses against cancer)? I certainly wouldn’t give up on scientific medicine, but if I can give the drugs a boost, well, so much the better.

It seems, for example, that part of what is going on in cancer is that tumors have ingenious ways of avoiding notice by the body’s immune defenses. If immune cells can’t recognize tumors as hostile intruders, they won’t attack. Some current immunotherapy drugs, the “checkpoint inhibitors,” address this difficulty; as I understand it, the specific problem they address is that tumors fool immune cells’ “checkpoints,” and the way they address this problem is to inhibit – turn off – those checkpoints. So presumably the same result could be achieved if I could somehow order my immune system to turn off those checkpoints.

Could I possibly do this? I really don’t know. I do know that cancer affects people in very mysterious ways. Some people go into remission without using any of the apparatus of modern scientific medicine. What have these people done to achieve this? Again, I don’t know. But I think it stands to reason that if people have any power to control how their immune systems function, they need to try to exercise that power in order to activate it. I haven’t done by any means as much of this as I’ve meant to, but lately I’ve been thinking more about how to go about it.

How one should exercise this power, even if it exists, is mysterious. Maybe the right approach is to seek a zen tranquility, in which the body moves of its own accord towards a natural harmony. A visualization CD that I have encourages you to visualize friendly magical beings around a powerful, healing light (though it has some tougher images of immune cells at work as well). Or perhaps, particularly with respect to checkpoint inhibitors, one should visualize the immune cells achieving a form of grace, in which each one “was blind but now I see,” and I’ve tried to visualize exactly this.

But I also incline to another strategy. Good health may feel like natural harmony or salvation, but the microscopic world of the immune system doesn’t seem very zen. It might be more accurate to describe the immune system as a regime of constant slaughter, in which your body’s cells set out to destroy the agents of illness that they encounter. Here’s a description of the functioning of “killer T cells,” from a google search: “When the perfectly shaped virus antigen on an infected cell fits into the Killer T-cell receptor, the T-cell releases perforin and cytotoxins. Perforin first makes a pore, or hole, in [the] membrane of the infected cell. Cytotoxins go directly inside the cell through this pore, destroying it and any viruses inside.” This is the world of violence, and that violence against the tumors is exactly what I want to incite. So perhaps the right image to visualize is of immune cells like soldiers, equipped with night goggles to make sure the cancer cells cannot hide under cover of darkness, and ready to attack with all their might – and I’ve tried this too.

Perhaps, however, images that try to echo real elements of the immune system are too literalistic. Maybe a better possibility is more metaphorical: if I want the tumors gone, what I want is for them to be erased from my body. Teresa imagines, and I’ve tried to as well, an eraser vigorously attacking each of the tumors. This image of erasure strikes me as vivid and physical and also a bit funny, and all of that may be ideal.

Or maybe one should simply send out a direction to the immune system, telling it to attack the tumors. This may be a call which there are no circuits to carry and no recipients to answer. Or it may be the kind of call that begins the difficult process of learning to do something you never had to do before. In any event, the only way to find out is to try.  


Sunday, February 26, 2017

Where things stand now

Here’s the latest news: It appears that the new tumor really is a new tumor – it didn’t exist before November 2016 and, based on the blood biopsy they’ve already done, it seems to have a different genetic makeup than my earlier tumors did. Our oncologist feels this is a development that needs to be nipped in the bud, so she’s switched my chemotherapy. I’m now off the old systemic drug, gemcitabine, which she feels should have stopped this new tumor from growing if it was still as effective as it should be. She’s also stopped the pump chemotherapy drug, FUDR, though we think she hasn’t altogether given up on this one. Instead of all of this, she’s now put me on a biweekly dose of two new chemotherapy drugs.

One I get at Sloan Kettering: irinitocan (nickname: “I ran to the can” – but fortunately I haven’t had much digestive excitement, yet). This one is actually preceded by yet another drug, leucovorin, a “folic acid derivative” which evidently paves the way for irinitocan to be as effective as possible by enabling it to stay in the body longer. Leucovorin isn’t exactly a chemotherapy drug in itself, however, which is why I said I’ve started on two new chemotherapy drugs, even though in fact I’m getting three new medications.

The other chemotherapy drug is called 5FU (also known as fluorouracil), and is apparently related to FUDR, which is one reason we don’t think Dr. Lowery has given up on FUDR. (Teresa thinks that the pump chemotherapy had to stop for the time being so that I could get as much systemic chemotherapy as possible, and that tradeoff makes sense especially if the 5FU is actually delivering a hit similar to what the pump FUDR would have.) I get part of this at Sloan Kettering in an injection called “the push,” but then the rest of it – “the bottle” – comes from a little cylinder called a Dosi-Fuser (diagram here), which continues the delivery of the medication via my port over a 48-hour period. I am not thrilled to be attached to this cylinder for 48 hours, but it’s only an inconvenience so I will get used to it. Actually it’s also bad for my reputation as an arbiter of fashion, but that too I will endure.

The plan is for me to do four rounds of these drugs – each round separated by two weeks – and then it will be time for another scan, probably in late March, to see whether they are working as we hope. My first round was two weeks ago, the second concluded earlier today. The side effects from the first round were not much fun; apparently “flu-like symptoms” are not uncommon, and I had something on those lines for a few days, and not much energy for several more days after that. But in the course of all this I remembered that the first round of my original chemotherapy, back in December 2015, also was pretty tough (I wound up in the emergency room with a fever, which fortunately they brought under control quickly). But once I got used to the routine it actually went quite smoothly for many subsequent rounds. This time, for the second round, Sloan Kettering prescribed additional anti-side-effect drugs to accompany the chemotherapy drugs themselves, and we’re hoping that the net result will be gentler. In any case, I felt well enough to travel with Teresa to see my daughter’s college dance company – which she’s loved for four years and is now the company manager of – have their spring show. And my Dosi-Fuser stayed reasonably well out of sight!

As part of all this, Teresa’s medical expertise is expanding. You may remember that when the incision from my pump surgery opened up slightly, it was Teresa who dressed the wound every day till it sealed itself up nicely. Now it’s Teresa who disconnects the Dosi-Fuser from my port when the 48 hour delivery period is over. The first round Teresa did the disconnection step by step under the guiding eyes of a very helpful nurse at Sloan Kettering, but for this round Teresa disconnected me at home, following just the video and written instructions that Sloan Kettering gave us. Everything went smoothly – yay, Teresa! (And the great advantage of her disconnecting me at home is that we don’t have to spend half a day going into New York City to have the same thing done by their staff.)  

Meanwhile, Teresa feels that our anti-cancer visualization efforts over the past months were incomplete. We focused on wiping out the existing tumors, and they did in fact get smaller. But we forgot about also preventing the emergence of brand new ones. So we plan to be more comprehensive over the coming weeks, and hope that those of you who’ve been sending thoughts and prayers our way – all deeply appreciated – will do so too!

Saturday, May 28, 2016

Churchill and cancer

The other night Teresa and I watched an HBO movie about Churchill during World War II. Here's one of the things he said, in a speech to Parliament in June 1940 as the German Army swept through West Europe: 

[W]e shall defend our island, whatever the cost may be. We shall fight on the beaches, we shall fight on the landing grounds, we shall fight in the fields and in the streets, we shall fight in the hills; we shall never surrender[.]

The speech helped sustain Britain’s morale in very dark days, and the story of that fight is still gripping. But it occurred to me afterwards that Churchill’s words also provide a pretty good metaphor for what’s involved in fighting off cancer.


This is what’s needed: to mobilize every cell in the body to fight the disease. Churchill’s words, conjuring up images of Britain’s fields and streets and hills, helped the people of Britain to visualize the struggle ahead and commit to it. Visualization, however, isn’t just a rhetorical move; it’s also a technique for people suffering from illness to envision and so help elicit their own physical triumph over their disease. 

The visualization techniques I’ve tried so far tend to be more spiritual and less martial than Churchill, and I think that their quieter reassurance has been helpful. Now, though, I’m feeling that Churchill’s powerful picture of a nation committed to the fight can also help me to mobilize each of my cells for the fight I’m in.